BigCommerce vs Shopify: Which Is Better for Your Business?

Deciding between BigCommerce and Shopify is super important for your business because it shapes how you’ll be online and grow. Both are great for e-commerce, but they have different strengths. BigCommerce has lots of built-in features, while Shopify is known for being easy to use and has tons of apps and designs.

As a business owner, you need to think about which one fits best with your goals, what tech skills you have, and where you see your business going. So, in the big world of online selling, which one, BigCommerce or Shopify, will really help your business grow and succeed?

Introduction to BigCommerce vs Shopify

When starting an online store, choosing the right e-commerce platform is crucial. BigCommerce and Shopify are two popular platforms for selling stuff online. They both have tools to help businesses make websites, manage products, and process sales. But they’re a bit different.

BigCommerce has lots of features and lets you customize a lot. Shopify is easier to use and looks really nice. It also has tons of apps you can add. To choose between them, think about things like how much they cost, how they look, what they can do, and what your business needs.

Overview of BigCommerce vs Shopify

• Pricing: Shopify and BigCommerce have different pricing plans. Shopify charges transaction fees unless you use Shopify Payments, while BigCommerce has sales thresholds for its plans.
• Design: Shopify has more themes and a simpler web builder. BigCommerce focuses on features and customization.
• E-commerce Tools: BigCommerce offers more built-in e-commerce features like SEO settings and product reviews. Shopify has many apps to add features.
• SEO and Marketing: Both platforms have good SEO tools. BigCommerce has advanced SEO, while Shopify has lots of marketing apps.
• Support and Resources: Shopify and BigCommerce offer 24/7 support, extensive knowledge bases, and community forums. However, the level of support and resources may vary based on the plan chosen.
• International Sales and Multi-channel Selling: Both platforms support international sales and multi-channel selling, allowing integration with various marketplaces and social media platforms.
• Performance and Uptime: Shopify and BigCommerce both boast high performance and uptime rates, ensuring that online stores remain operational and efficient.
• App Ecosystem: Shopify has a larger app marketplace compared to BigCommerce, providing users with a wider range of options to enhance their store’s functionality.

Pricing and Transaction Fees

Pricing and Monthly Plans

• Different Plans for Different Needs: Both BigCommerce and Shopify offer different pricing plans starting from around $29/month for the basic plan and going up for fancier features.
• What You Get: BigCommerce usually gives more cool stuff in its basic plans compared to Shopify. With Shopify, you might need to buy extra apps for similar features.
• Bang for Your Buck: BigCommerce might give you more for your money in the basic plan, but Shopify has a cheaper starting option for super small businesses or newbies, starting at $5/month.

Transaction Fees

• Shopify’s Fees: Shopify applies transaction fees ranging from 0.5% to 2% unless you use Shopify Payments, its in-house payment processing service.
• BigCommerce’s Approach: BigCommerce stands out for charging no transaction fees, regardless of the payment gateway used, which can lead to cost savings, especially for high-volume sellers​.

Credit Card and Third-Party Payment Processing Fees

• Payment Options: Both platforms let you use different payment systems like PayPal, Stripe, and more. They usually charge around 2.2% to 2.9%, plus a flat fee for each sale.
• Custom Deals: BigCommerce and Shopify talk to payment systems to get good rates, but the actual costs can change based on how much you sell, where you are, and your agreement with the payment system.
• How It Affects You: Even though you can try to keep fees low, paying for credit card and processing fees is something businesses always have to consider, and it affects how much money they make.

Ease of Use and User Interface

User Experience for New and Existing Business Owners

• Shopify: Easy to set up, Shopify has a simple interface perfect for beginners. It guides users through setting up their store step by step.
• BigCommerce: Also easy to use, BigCommerce offers more advanced features for those who know a bit about tech. It’s great for growing businesses but might take a bit more time to learn for new users.

The Simplicity of Shopify’s Interface Compared to BigCommerce’s Feature-Rich Platform

• Shopify: The platform is lauded for its minimalistic design, which makes it easier for users to find and use its features. Shopify’s dashboard and theme customization are streamlined, allowing users to focus on essential tasks without feeling overwhelmed​ .
• BigCommerce: Offers a robust set of features out of the box, which is advantageous for businesses looking for an all-in-one solution. However, the extensive functionalities can make the interface feel more cluttered and complex compared to Shopify’s more straightforward layout​ .

The Learning Curve Associated with Each Platform

• Shopify: Easy for beginners, Shopify is simple to learn and start using. It focuses on being user-friendly and guiding new store owners through the setup process without needing lots of technical skills.
• BigCommerce: Better for people who know a bit about online selling, BigCommerce has lots of features you can change. It’s more complicated to learn because there are more settings and choices to explore to get the most out of it.

Design and Customization Options

Range of Themes and Design Flexibility

• Shopify offers a vast array of themes, both free and paid, known for their aesthetic appeal and modern designs. Users can easily find themes that suit various business niches, with a focus on creating visually appealing and customer-friendly online stores. The themes are also customizable, allowing users to tweak the design to better fit their brand identity​.
• BigCommerce provides a selection of themes that are highly customizable and cater to a wide range of industries. While the number of themes is fewer than Shopify, BigCommerce’s themes are built to be fully responsive and can be customized extensively through HTML, CSS, and other web technologies, giving users more control over their site’s appearance and functionality​​.

Ability to Support Unique Branding and User Experience

• Shopify excels in offering a platform that allows for easy customization to support unique branding. With its user-friendly interface and drag-and-drop editor, Shopify makes it simple for merchants to personalize their stores, ensuring a unique user experience that aligns with their brand. The platform’s versatility in design options helps businesses create a distinctive online presence​.
• BigCommerce also supports unique branding with its advanced customization features. It offers more out-of-the-box functionality for customization compared to Shopify, making it a good choice for businesses with specific branding requirements. BigCommerce allows for deep customization of the storefront, enabling businesses to tailor their online presence to match their brand identity closely​.

Comparison of Mobile Integration and Responsiveness

Shopify works really well on mobile phones, making shopping easy and fun for customers who use their phones to shop. It makes sure that everything looks good and works smoothly on all devices, which can lead to more sales.

BigCommerce also works well on mobile devices like phones, tablets, and computers, but Shopify might be a bit better at making everything look neat and consistent. Still, BigCommerce is strong in giving a good shopping experience on any device.

E-commerce Features and Tools: BigCommerce vs. Shopify

Core Sales Features

• SSL Certificates: BigCommerce and Shopify both use SSL certificates to keep customer data safe during online transactions. This is important for keeping customers’ trust.
• Abandoned Cart Recovery: This feature is crucial for increasing conversion rates by reminding customers of items they left in the cart. Shopify offers abandoned cart recovery across all its plans, whereas BigCommerce starts offering this feature from its Plus plan​.
• Multi-Channel Selling: Both platforms support selling across various channels, including online marketplaces like Amazon, social media platforms, and physical locations. This integration helps businesses reach a broader audience and increase sales opportunities​.

Built-in Tools and Functionalities

Shopify is known for its ease of use and a wide range of built-in tools that accommodate businesses of all sizes. However, for more advanced features, users often need to install additional apps.

BigCommerce has more built-in features than Shopify right from the start, like better analytics, product reviews, and shipping options. This makes it a good deal for businesses wanting lots of tools without paying extra.

Inventory Management and Product Management Capabilities

• Inventory Management: BigCommerce and Shopify both help you keep track of what you have in stock. They let you know when items are running low and handle sales through different places. BigCommerce has some extra tools for sorting and showing products differently right from the start.
• Product Management: For handling products, both platforms are good at adding lots of items at once, managing different versions of a product, and organizing them well. BigCommerce gives more options for changing product details directly, while Shopify is easier and faster to set up.

Apps and Integrations

Availability and Variety of Native and Third-Party Apps

• Shopify: Offers a vast array of both native and third-party apps in its app store, exceeding over 3,000 options. The apps cover a wide range of functionalities, including marketing, sales, social media integration, accounting, and customer service. Shopify’s own apps, such as Shopify Email, are designed to integrate seamlessly with the platform.
• BigCommerce: Provides a more selective range of apps compared to Shopify, with over 800 available in its marketplace. BigCommerce focuses on offering more built-in features within the platform, reducing the need for additional apps. However, it still supports essential integrations with major tools for marketing, analytics, and payment processing.

Impact of Apps on Store Functionality and User Experience

• Shopify: Shopify has a lot of apps that help store owners add new features and improve their online shops. These apps are easy to use and cover many needs like keeping track of stock and keeping customers coming back. This makes Shopify very flexible and can make the online shop work better and easier to use.
• BigCommerce: BigCommerce comes with many features already included, so store owners might not need as many extra apps. This makes things simpler and easier to manage. But BigCommerce also has apps available, so store owners can still add special tools if they need to.

Comparison of the Costs and Benefits of App Integrations

• Costs:
  • Shopify’s apps vary in price, with many free options and others requiring a monthly subscription. The cost can add up for stores needing multiple paid apps to extend their functionality.
  • BigCommerce’s approach means fewer necessary apps but this could also limit flexibility for highly specialized needs. Some BigCommerce apps can be expensive, but the overall need for paid apps may be less.
• Benefits:
  • Shopify’s extensive app market means virtually limitless possibilities for customizing and extending the functionality of an online store, offering a benefit of adaptability and scalability.
  • BigCommerce’s comprehensive built-in features can reduce the total cost of ownership and simplify operations, presenting a benefit in terms of reduced complexity and potentially lower ongoing expenses.

SEO and Marketing Tools

Built-in SEO capabilities and additional marketing tools are available

BigCommerce and Shopify help your business show up more in search results. BigCommerce has features like automatic picture fixing, changeable web addresses, and easy description settings for better search results.

Shopify has fewer built-in search features but offers many apps to improve this. Both platforms let you use social media, Google Ads, and email to promote your business.

The effectiveness of these tools in driving traffic and sales

• Effective SEO tools are crucial for increasing visibility and attracting traffic to e-commerce sites. Both platforms have shown competency in this area, with users reporting improvements in search engine rankings and traffic​​.
• Marketing tools like email campaigns, social media integration, and Google Ads have been instrumental in driving sales by reaching a broader audience and engaging customers effectively.

Comparison of promotional features like banners, coupons, and email marketing templates

• BigCommerce gives you tools like banners, coupons, and email ads to attract customers and boost sales.
• Shopify is great at promotion too, offering a wide range of apps for marketing, including email marketing, banner making, and custom discounts.
• Both BigCommerce and Shopify help with sales promotions, but Shopify has more apps for a variety of marketing activities.

Performance and Reliability

Website Load Times and Uptime Statistics

• Shopify and BigCommerce boast impressive uptime statistics, nearing 99.9%, ensuring that online stores remain accessible to customers with minimal downtime.
• Load times are crucial for customer retention; both platforms offer fast load times, but specific performance can depend on the chosen themes, number of apps installed, and overall site complexity.

Impact of Performance on Customer Experience and Sales

Websites need to load fast and work well to make customers happy. If a website is slow, people may leave and not buy anything. A good online store helps make buying easy and builds trust, so customers come back. If a website loads slowly, it can drive customers away, which could mean less money made.

Mobile and Desktop Speed Comparisons

BigCommerce and Shopify both work well on mobile phones and computers because they know people shop a lot on their phones.

Websites that load quickly on phones tend to get more visitors and sales. Good performance on computers is also key because many people still use them to shop. Both BigCommerce and Shopify make sure their websites load fast and look good on all devices.

Conclusion

Choosing BigCommerce or Shopify depends on cost, how easy they are to use, their design, what they can do, the apps they work with, how well they do in search engines, how fast and reliable they are, and the support they offer.

BigCommerce is good for businesses making lots of sales because it doesn’t charge extra per sale, and it has many features. Shopify is easier to use, has a lot of apps, and lets you change the design more. Your choice should match what your business needs, how tech-savvy you are, your budget, and your plans for growing your business. Both are good options for online stores and can help your business succeed.

FAQs